nav emailalert searchbtn searchbox tablepage yinyongbenwen piczone journalimg journalInfo searchdiv qikanlogo popupnotification paper paperNew
2025, 02, No.191 101-111
中国多代间的教育流动研究:四代人的证据
基金项目(Foundation): 国家社会科学基金重大项目“共同富裕视角下培育内生动力解决相对贫困的长效机制研究”(23VRC035); 国家自然科学基金面上项目“相对贫困的财税治理研究”(72073081);国家自然科学基金重点专项项目“基于人口结构变化的税制结构优化路径研究”(72442003)
邮箱(Email):
DOI: 10.14134/j.cnki.cn33-1337/c.2025.02.010
摘要:

基于中国微观数据的四代家庭样本,研究了多代间的教育流动,并对其流动机制进行了检验,结果显示:中国三代内具有教育持续性的特征;三代内教育持续性存在城乡、性别异质性,城市中祖父母的教育影响比农村的影响大,男性教育程度与其祖父的教育联系更大,而女性教育程度与其祖母的教育联系更大;三代内教育持续性的传导机制是直接互动渠道;中国不存在四代间的教育持续性。

Abstract:

Based on a four-generation family sample from micro-data in China, this study explores intergenerational educational mobility and examines its mechanisms. The results show that there is a characteristic feature of educational persistence within three generations in China. There exists urban-rural and gender heterogeneity in educational persistence within three generations: the educational influence of grandparents in urban areas is greater than that in rural areas, the educational level of males is more closely linked to their grandfathers, while the educational level of females is more closely linked to their grandmothers. The transmission mechanism of educational persistence within three generations is through direct interaction channels. There is no educational persistence across four generations in China.

参考文献

[1]MARE R D.A Multigenerational View of Inequality [J].Demography,2011,48(1):1-23.

[2]SHAVIT Y.Stratification in Higher Education:A Comparative Study [M].Stanford:Stanford University Press,2007.

[3]JENCKS C.Inequality:A Reassessment of the Effect of Family and Schooling in America [M].New York:Basic Books,1972.

[4]BREEN R,GOLDTHORPE J H.Explaining Educational Differentials:Towards a Formal Rational Action Theory [J].Rationality and Society,1997,9(3):275-305.

[5]JAEGER M M.The Extended Family and Children's Educational Success [J].American Sociological Review,2012,77(6):903-922.

[6]SOLON G.Theoretical Models of Inequality Transmission Across Multiple Generations [J].Research in Social Stratification and Mobility,2014,35(1):13-18.

[7]BECKER G S,TOMES N.Human Capital and the Rise and Fall of Families [J].Journal of Labor Economics,1986,4(3):S1-S39.

[8]ZENG Z,XIE Y.The Effects of Grandparents on Children's Schooling:Evidence from Rural China [J].Demography,2014,51(2):599-617.

[9]ANDERSON L R,SHEPPARD P,MONDEN C W S.Grandparent Effects on Educational Outcomes:A Systematic Review [J].Sociological Science,2018,5(6):114-142.

[10]WARREN J R,HAUSER R M.Social Stratification across Three Generations:New Evidence from The Wisconsin Longitudinal Study [J].American Sociological Review,1997,62(4):561-572.

[11]HODGE R W.Occupational Mobility as A Probability Process [J].Demography,1966,3(1):19-34.

[12]BEHRMAN J,TAUBMAN P.Intergenerational Earnings Mobility in the United States:Some Estimates and A Test of Becker's Intergenerational Endowments Model [J].The Review of Economics and Statistics,1985,67(1):144-151.

[13]PETERS H E.Patterns of Intergenerational Mobility in Income and Earnings [J].The Review of Economics and Statistics,1992,74(3):456-466.

[14]RAZZU G,WAMBILE A.Three-generation Educational Mobility in Six African Countries [R].Whiteknights:Department of Economics,University of Reading,2020.

[15]LINDAHL M,PALME M,MASSIH S S,et al.Long-Term Intergenerational Persistence of Human Capital:An Empirical Analysis of Four Generations [J].Journal of Human Resources,2015,50(1):1-33.

[16]KROEGER S,THOMPSON O.Educational Mobility across Three Generations of American Women [J].Economics of Education Review,2016,53(4):72-86.

[17]LI M H,CAO J.Multi-generational Educational Mobility in China in the Twentieth Century [J].China Economic Review,2023,80(4):101990.

[18]DRIBE M,HELGERTZ J,VAN DE PUTTE B.Did Social Mobility Increase during the Industrialization Process?A Micro-level Study of A Transforming Community in Southern Sweden 1828—1968 [J].Research in Social Stratification and Mobility,2015,41(3):25-39.

[19]DRIBE M,HELGERTZ J.The Lasting Impact of Grandfathers:Class,Occupational Status,and Earnings over Three Generations in Sweden 1815—2011 [J].The Journal of Economic History,2016,76(4):969-1000.

[20]KOLK M,H?LLSTEN M.Demographic and Educational Success of Lineages in Northern Sweden [J].Population and Development Review,2017,43(3):491-512.

[21]MODALSLI J.Multigenerational Persistence:Evidence from 146 Years of Administrative Data [J].Journal of Human Resources,2023,58(3):929-961.

[22]H?LLSTEN M,KOLK M.The Shadow of Peasant Past:Seven Generations of Inequality Persistence in Northern Sweden [J].American Journal of Sociology,2023,128(6):1716-1760.

[23]SHIUE C H.An Analysis with Five Linked Generations in China,1300—1900 [R].Colorado:University of Colorado,NBER,CEPR,2017.

[24]CLARK G,CUMMINS N.Intergenerational Wealth Mobility in England,1858—2012:Surnames and Social Mobility [J].The Economic Journal,2015,125(582):61-85.

[25]STUHLER J.Mobility Across Multiple Generations:The Iterated Regression Fallacy [R].Bonn:Institute of Labor Economics,2012.

[26]BRAUN S T,STUHLER J.The Transmission of Inequality Across Multiple Generations:Testing Recent Theories with Evidence from Germany [J].The Economic Journal,2018,128(609):576-611.

[27]CAO J,LI M H.Social Mobility across Three Generations:Evidence from China [R].Ames:Department of Economics,Lowa State University,2019.

[28]ZHU H,OTSUKI T.Can Two Consecutive Generations' Data Predict Long-term Intergenerational Transition?Evidence from China with Three Generations [R].Toyonaka:Osaka School of International Public Policy,2018.

[29]DEINDL C,TIEBEN N.Resources of Grandparents:Educational Outcomes across Three Generations in Europe and Israel [J].Journal of Marriage and Family,2017,79(3):769-783.

[30]GIRAUDEAU C,DUFLOS M,CHASSEIGNE G.Adolescents' Conceptions of “Good” Grandparents:A Reversal Theory Approach [J].Journal of Intergenerational Relationships,2022,20(2):150-167.

[31]SOREK Y.Grandparental and Overall Social Support as Resilience Factors in Coping with Parental Conflict among Children of Divorce [J].Children and Youth Services Review,2020,118(11):105443.

[32]PFEFFER F T.Multigenerational Approaches to Social Mobility.A Multifaceted Research Agenda [J].Research in Social Stratification and Mobility,2014,35(1):1-12.

[33]BOL T,KALMIJIN M.Grandparents' Resources and Grandchildren's Schooling:Does Grandparental Involvement Moderate the Grandparent Effect?[J].Social Science Research,2016,55(1):155-170.

[34]HERTEL F R,GROH-SAMBERG O.Class Mobility across Three Generations in the U.S.and Germany [J].Research in Social Stratification and Mobility,2014,35(1):35-52.

[35]CHAN T W,BOLIVER V.The Grandparents Effect in Social Mobility:Evidence from British Birth Cohort Studies [J].American Sociological Review,2013,78(4):662-678.

[36]BOSERUP S H,KOPCZUK W,KREINER C T.Intergenerational Wealth Mobility:Evidence from Danish Wealth Records of Three Generations [R].Copenhagen:University of Copenhagen,Department of Economics,2013.

[37]JOHNSON L T,KANE R J.Deserts of Disadvantage:The Diffuse Effects of Structural Disadvantage on Violence in Urban Communities [J].Crime & Delinquency,2018,64(2):143-165.

[38]THERON L,VAN RENSBURG A.Resilience over Time:Learning from School-attending Adolescents Living in Conditions of Structural Inequality [J].Journal of Adolescence,2018,67(1):167-178.

[39]FERRIE J,MASSEY C,ROTHBAUM J.Do Grandparents and Great-Grandparents Matter?Multigenerational Mobility in the US,1910—2013 [R].Cambridge:National Bureau of Economic Research,2016.

[40]KING V,ELDER JR G H.The Legacy of Grandparenting:Childhood Experiences with Grandparents and Current Involvement with Grandchildren [J].Journal of Marriage and Family,1997,59(4):848-859.

[41]COATE P,DALTON M,HOTZ V,et al.The Family that Shares Is the Family that Cares:Are Extended Families Efficient [R].Dallas:Population Association of America 2010 Annual Meeting Program,2010.

[42]MAZUMDER B.Estimating the Intergenerational Elasticity and Rank Association in the United States:Overcoming the Current Limitations of Tax Data [M]// CAPPELLARI L,POLACHEK S W,TATSTRAMOS K.Inequality:Causes and Consequences.Bingley:Emerald Group Publishing Limited,2016.

(1)值得指出的是,无论是以受访者作为第四代还是以受访者的子女作为第四代抑或是以受访者的孙子女作为第四代,如果选择第四代的年龄大于18岁,G1—G4的混合截面的样本量都显得过少(不足100个),为此,可复制性中也只分析了三代内的教育流动情况。

(2)以第四代男性、女性的最高教育程度分别为因变量的线性概率模型结果大致相同。

基本信息:

DOI:10.14134/j.cnki.cn33-1337/c.2025.02.010

中图分类号:G521

引用信息:

[1]解垩.中国多代间的教育流动研究:四代人的证据[J].浙江工商大学学报,2025,No.191(02):101-111.DOI:10.14134/j.cnki.cn33-1337/c.2025.02.010.

基金信息:

国家社会科学基金重大项目“共同富裕视角下培育内生动力解决相对贫困的长效机制研究”(23VRC035); 国家自然科学基金面上项目“相对贫困的财税治理研究”(72073081);国家自然科学基金重点专项项目“基于人口结构变化的税制结构优化路径研究”(72442003)

检 索 高级检索

引用

GB/T 7714-2015 格式引文
MLA格式引文
APA格式引文